Genius Hour – My Epiphany!

This is my third year using Genius Hour in my English classroom.  While I’ve loved it and feel using this type of PBL has completely changed my classroom, I’ve always had this feeling that I was missing something, that there was an element that was just not quite there.  Yesterday, the students were showing their second post on their social media sites (one of three requirements to Genius Hour, the other two being that their project must help someone or others and it must include research to show knowledge gained), and it hit me – my epiphany!  With all my focus on using textual evidence to back up arguments in their writing in my classroom, I had never thought to use this for their Genius Hour.  I’ve never asked my students to show proof that what they were doing, making, or discovering for Genius Hour was valid or successful (using their own personal measures for success, of course) or benefitted others in some way.  That was it – my missing piece!

This all happened yesterday when a student asked me if she could change her Genius Hour. She just wasn’t feeling passionate about her first choice and did not feel it would be something to which she could devote the next six months.  I told her that was fine and asked her what she would prefer doing; she explained that body confidence was something she always struggled with and it was a topic she felt she could educate people about.  Then, without any thought on my part, I blurted out, “So, how will you prove that you were able to teach others about this?”.  It must have been a knee-jerk reaction because it’s a concept I nag my kids about all the time in regards to their writing, but it just seemed to fit perfectly with Genius Hour. I knew instantly that I needed to incorporate this idea into this project, because I could tell the question furthered my student’s thinking and made her consider the “how”, rather than just the “what” of her project.  This then led to a very productive conversation about ways she could prove that what she has done has educated people and made a difference in some way.  She talked about making polls, filming interviews with people, as well as a few other really good ideas.  But what I found was it deepened her thinking and gave her more of a connection with the project.

One final thought about the importance of having students prove their success and/or impact with their Genius Hour Projects has to do with teaching; there is connection between what the kids are doing for their projects and what we do as teachers.  While we, as teachers, may start out with great intentions when presenting a lesson, how will we really know we made an impact or educated our kids unless we assess them?  We have to use summative and formative assessment to make sure that what we are doing and teaching is effective and that the kids are actually learning as a result.  My approach to Genius Hour the past two years was exactly like teaching without assessment; I’ve allowed the kids to show what they’ve done, without challenging them to prove its effectiveness or benefit to others.  That is changing immediately!  I’m actually really excited to add this new layer to Genius Hour, because I know this will challenge the kids’ thinking even more and their experiences and results will be so much better…saying-it-is-one-thing-but-proving-it-is-another-quote-1




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s